Book Reviews · Books · Faith · George Lucas · Kenobi · Star Wars · The Clone Wars

Dark Disciple – Review

Dark_Disciple_CoverWhen Disney purchased Lucasfilm in the fall of 2012 it marked the end of The Clone Wars. It was as if millions of voices suddenly cried out in horror, yet instead of being silenced, they have only continued to speak strongly, with the hashtag #SaveTheCloneWars still a staple of Twitter to this day. Since it’s demise, Dave Filoni and Pablo Hidalgo have worked tirelessly to find the best venue for all the displaced stories that were in development. The Lost Missions were released on Netflix, there have been two releases of arcs on in animatic form, as well as a comic book  chronicling more of Darth Maul’s story.

It is no surprise that one of these untold stories has found it’s way into a novel. The newest edition to Star Wars canon is Dark Disciple by Christie Golden, which was to have been an eight part arc in an upcoming Clone Wars season. It follows up on the character Quinlan Vos who is tasked by the Jedi Council to assassinate Count Dooku after he commits near complete genocide. Vos’ mission is to secretly recrute discarded assassin Asajj Ventress to take out the Separatist leader at all costs. What follows is a tale of darkness, deception, hope and ultimately redemption.

The Road to Hell

One of the strengths of The Clone Wars has been the way it fills in the gap between Episodes II and III. Lucas has mentioned before that in the course of the Skywalker saga there was not the time to dive into the war itself. The Clone Wars does a spectacular job at showing the slow slide down the slippery slope that the Jedi have been put on as war was thrust upon them, They have gone from keepers of the peace to soldiers, in a war that has been manufactured as their doom. Disciple is one of the finest examples at how far the Jedi Order has been eroded by the war. It has begun to chip away at their morality and connection to the light. They are willing to put aside what they know is right for a chance and victory, yet the price may be more that they can bare. The road to hell is paved with good intentions and that is the case here as the Jedi Council authorizes a dark mission for Quinlan Vos to enlist the help of Ventress through deception to assassinate Count Dooku. Irony of it all, the greatest proponent on the Council is Windu who once defended him to Padme by saying, “You know, My Lady, Count Dooku was once a Jedi. He couldn’t assassinate anyone. It’s not in his character.”  Unfortunately the war has created an atmosphere for the Jedi where what was once unthinkable has become tolerable or even acceptable. The corruption of the Jedi is almost complete.

It’s a powerful reminder of just how easy it is for the truth to slip away from us, even when we think we are doing the right thing. Circumstances cannot craft right and wrong as the Jedi learn here. Embracing even the smallest amount of the the dark side can destroy lives.

Interview with Christie Golden

The Power of Sacrifice – Spoilers 

One of the greatest character arcs in The Clone Wars is that of Asajj Ventress. At the resent Star Wars Celebration, Dave Filoni mentioned that Lucas was not happy having Ventress as an acolyte of Dooku. George felt like her story would be much stronger if she were to make her own way and boy was he right.

The last time Ventress was seen in the show she had assisted Ahsoka who was on the run from the Jedi Order. Her character had already begun to turn from the darkness in the Darth Maul arc from season 4 where she saved a young girl who was about to become a slave wife.

As Dark Disciple begins Asajj is still working the bounty hunter scene, going it alone when Vos shows up. As they begin a fledgling partnership, she begins to open her heart to the possibility that she could have more. The most powerful theme in the book becomes the redemption of Ventress, a character who has been to the brink of the abyss and clawed her way back. It is her love of Vos and her willingness to embrace the way of the light that enables her to sacrifice herself for another. She lives out the words of Jesus when he says, Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends.” The affect she has on Vos and Obi-Wan is profound. Obi-Wan specifically points out to the Council the error of their ways and just how much they can learn from Asajj. They have lost their way and turned to the dark side for answers, but is it though the light that the true power comes.

This story brought tears to my eyes as it illustrated the beautiful truth that no one is beyond redemption. Most of the time, people only lack the light to show them the way so it is our job to love those that others might see as unlovable. It is only through self sacrificial love that this can happen. People are not won by words but by actions and there is nothing more powerful than true love at work.

Kenobi and Yoda

UntitledAnother fascinating about Dark Disciple is the way Kenobi and Yoda seem to be setting themselves apart from the rest of the Jedi. Both of them are uncomfortable about the idea of an assassination mission. Kenobi voices strong opposition to the plan and even gets rather heated with Master Windu as the Council debates whether or not to pursue this dangerous idea. Kenobi seems to be channeling the defiance of Qui-Gon as he tries to steer the Council back towards the light. One character even remakes that Obi-Wan always strives to take the high road and see the best in people.

As the book progresses it is Kenobi and Yoda that have the hardest time believing Vos could have fallen to the dark side. They seem to be the only ones that still have faith in the Jedi’s ways. Not only do they have trust in Vos but they also give that trust to Ventress as well. Kenobi and Yoda, again and again in this book portrays the very best qualities of the Jedi, fighting for what is right and trusting in only incontrovertible evidence about the guilt of a trusted friend.

This book puts to rest any doubt that Yoda and Obi-Wan were the greatest Jedi and showing just why they survived. I’ve personally never been prouder of my favorite character Kenobi than when he stands before the Council at the end of the book and says,

“We lost our way,” Kenobi had said. “We lost it when we decided to use assassination, a practice so clearly of the dark side, for our own ends, well intentioned though they might have been. All that has happened since—Vos succumbing to the dark side, the deaths he has directly and indirectly caused, the secrets leaked, the worlds placed in jeopardy—all of this can be traced back to that single decision. Masters, I submit to you that Vos’s fall was of our making. And Asajj Ventress’s death is on all our hands. That Vos is here with us today, devastated but on the light path once more, is no credit to us, but to her. She died a true friend of the Jedi, and I believe that she deserves to be laid to rest with respect and care, with all gratitude for the life she gave and the life she has restored to us, and this bitter lesson that came at so dear a price. We are Jedi, and we must, all of us, always, remember what that means.”


Christie Golden has written the finest book in the new canon with Dark Disciple. The book immediately feels like an arc of The Clone Wars. In many ways it is a stinging reminder of just how much life was left in this show and the power it had to tell amazing stories. My sincere thanks to Dave Filoni and Pablo Hidalgo for continuing to find opportunities to get The Clone Wars content to fans any way they can. Dark Disciple is now my gold standard for what this new line of canon books can and should be. This book is rated a perfect 10.

And be sure to check out John Mills’ review who joined me for the discussion.

Book Reviews · Books · Kenobi · Star Wars · The Clone Wars · Uncategorized

Kenobi – Review

Star-Wars-Kenobi-Book-CoverThis will be a slightly different review than is normally seen on this blog. For the most part, I do not write with “I”, but here I shall. “Why” you may ask will I be changing up my review style; great question. The reason I will be doing so is because this is a personal subject for me. Obi-Wan Kenobi has been my favorite character since I first watched the original trilogy a long, long time ago. There was something about this enigmatic wizard that left me wanting to know more, to see more about him. I would have to wait a long time till the prequels came and gave me more Obi-Wan and I was thrilled. Ewan played him to perfection, yet I still wanted more. So Lucas and Filoni gave us The Clone Wars, which added to the character and enriched his history. There have even been book series about him by Jude Watson for children (which I have read many) but finally John Jackson Miller has been tapped to write an adult novel all about Kenobi. Sufficed to say as a huge Obi-Wan fan I could not have been more excited about a Star Wars novel. This is the story I have been waiting to see, Kenobi after Episode III and before Episode IV; the only question was, “Can this live up to my massive expectations?”

Tusken_SWGTCGI’ll answer the question, as not to leave you hanging too long; this book lives up to my expectations, mostly. Miller has his work cut out for him. There are so many fans who have been clamoring for this novel for so long, I cannot imagine the pressure he must have felt. First off, he creates a great feel to the novel from the very beginning. Much has been made in reviews of the “wild-west” atmosphere and they are right on target. Tatooine is the perfect setting for a Star Wars western. As you read you can almost picture Monument Valley in a John Wayne epic with the lone rider making his way across the desert. There are all the classic tropes from westerns; the outpost on the edge of the frontier, the widow raising her kids alone, the big man who everyone looks too, raiders terrorizing settlers, the list could go on. Yet in all of it, it feels fresh in Miller’s hands. He is able to give us a clear picture of what it is like to live on this desolate world from the perspective of the settlers and the Sand People. (It should be noted that this is one of the clearest and most in-depth looks at the Tusken Raiders in the Star Wars Expanded Universe and adds a lot of dimension to the story). Since I am going to stay spoiler free I will not say much more here except this is a very good book.

With the expectations that I had going into the book, there was no way it could live up to my lofty desires. If there is one downfall of the story it is that there is not enough Kenobi. I had hoped to really get inside his mind, see his interactions with Qui-Gon in meditation and feel like I was living in his shoes. Miller gives us some of this, but in my opinion, not enough. I was disappointed that the meditation time with Qui-Gon was completely one-sided, I had hoped to see more about this connection and understand how it works; really see Obi-Wan learn the secrets of the Force. I come away from the book wanting more Kenobi and from a book with his name as the title, I would have thought he would have been the centerpiece the entire story.

So, here we are, at the end of the review. I recommend this book highly, even with my frustrations. This is one of the best Star Wars books I have read in a long time. I hope that we will see more like this and of course, even more of Kenobi.

Map of Tatooine: